Book Banning: Examples through the Centuries

In 325, A.D., censorship appeared with a new face: the Catholic Church. Thaleia, a poetic expression of an unothodox view of the nature of Christ was the first writing to be banned by the Catholic Church. The Council of Nicaea also exiled the book's author, Arius. The Church was at the center of book banning for centuries, and the Bible itself was at the center of much of the controversy. For instance, the first English translation of the Bible, made by William Tyndale in 1525, was damned as "pernicious merchandise" by the clergy. Tyndale was burned at the stake in 1546, and in 1555 all of his books were banned by Queen Mary for being against the Catholic faith (Haight, 12-13).

In 1559, Pope Paul IV issued the first Index Librorum Prohibitorum, a specific list of books that the Catholic Church prohibited Catholics from reading. Because the Catholic faith dominated the intellectual life of Europe through these centuries, this list had a significant impact. In 1949, the list still had 255 titles on it (Burke, 52). Pope Paul VI terminated the Index in 1966 (Haight, 16).

Desiderius Erasmus, noted for making good use of Johan Gutenberg's printing press, had all of his work condemned by the Index of 1559 (Haight, 9). The significant increase in the number of banned books in the 16th century probably has to do with both the Index and the printing press, putting Erasmus in the center of things. For more information and illustrations, check http://spencer.lib.ku.edu/exhibits/bannedbooks/variouscountries.html.

Why did the Catholic Church ban so many books? The Church, as "the custodian of divine revelation," had the responsiblity "to interpret the teachings of Christ" and therefore had to control the reading material of Catholics (Burke, 3). The practice protected the innocent, as Plato wanted to do, but it also invested much power in the authorities who decided what could and could not be read. Was anything similar happening across the Atlantic, where the colonies were in the process of becoming the United States?

Next...